"Example: an Ontario-born grandfather, three generations"
Last checked against official sources on .

The family (fictional): Emma, born 1990 in Ohio. Her father, David, born 1962 in Michigan. David's father, Robert, born 1931 in London, Ontario, who moved to Detroit in 1955, became a U.S. citizen in 1961 and died in 2010.
Does the rule reach Emma?
Robert was born in Ontario in 1931, before Canadian citizenship existed, when people born in Canada were British subjects. Someone born in Canada who was living there when the 1947 Act took effect would normally have become a citizen on January 1, 1947. Naturalizing in the U.S. in 1961 would have cost him that citizenship under the rules of the time, and IRCC says the 2009 changes gave citizenship back to people who lost it after becoming citizens on January 1, 1947. David, born abroad to a Canadian, is first generation. Emma, born before December 15, 2025, is covered by Bill C-3's removal of the first-generation limit. Robert's death in 2010 doesn't matter: section 3(1.5) of the Act covers it.
Nobody in the line formally renounced, and there's no adoption. On these facts, the line is likely good.
The chain
| Person | Document | Where from | Shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Emma | Ohio birth certificate, the version naming both parents | Ohio Department of Health, Vital Statistics | Emma's parents: David and her mother |
| David | Michigan birth certificate, the version naming both parents | Michigan's state vital records office | David's parents: Robert and his mother |
| Robert | Ontario certified copy of birth registration | ServiceOntario (1931 is after the Archives cut-off) | Born in London, Ontario, and his parents |
| David's mother's marriage record, if her surname on David's certificate differs from her birth name | County where the marriage licence was issued | Not needed for the Canadian line, which runs through Robert |
Emma also needs two pieces of ID, two citizenship photos and the $75 CAD fee receipt.
The hard part: ordering Robert's record
Robert died, so ServiceOntario issues only the certified copy of the birth registration, and only to next of kin, the executor or the estate administrator. David, as Robert's son, is next of kin and can order it. If David had also died, Emma could apply as extended next of kin only if all of Robert's next of kin had died.
What Emma doesn't need
- Robert's U.S. naturalization papers. They can confirm his birthplace, but the Ontario registration does that directly.
- Robert's death certificate, unless ServiceOntario asks for it with David's order.
- A citizenship certificate for David. The chain proves his status as part of Emma's application. David can apply separately if he wants his own.
Why this is close to the easiest case
Two U.S. certificates and one Ontario record, all from the original issuing offices, with a living next of kin who can order the Canadian document. Most grandparent claims that stall do so because one of those three conditions fails.
Related
This page explains the rules in general terms. It is not legal advice and doesn't assess your case. The Citizenship Act and IRCC's proof of citizenship pages are the final word.